← All sessions

MedTech Leading Voice · 6 Aug 2026

Beyond the Protocol: A Realistic Resource and Planning Guide for Human Factors Validation Success

Denise, Kira and Leah explain how planning and resourcing make human factors validation succeed, and where studies commonly fail.

Plays from YouTube when you press play. Cookie settings

What the session covered

Hosted by Sean Smith, this session featured Denise, Kira and Leah discussing the planning and resourcing work that sits behind a successful human factors validation. The speakers argued that much of this work is invisible to management and to teams outside human factors, which leads to unrealistic timelines, insufficient budgets and repeated studies. They set out six common mistakes: poor project scope and planning; mismanagement of project resources; weak recruitment planning; failure to dry run the protocol and use scenarios; use of poorly trained personnel; and underestimation of the time needed for qualitative analysis and reporting. Case studies covered a patient monitor, a diabetes study with adolescents and caregivers, and a robotic surgery system that had to repeat its validation after FDA questions. The speakers offered practical fixes, including early recruitment, pilot sessions, trained moderators and root cause probing. They also described the cost trade-off between planning now and paying later, gave a three-month planning rule of thumb, and suggested how to make the case to management. Q&A covered startup budgets, fixed timelines and summative usability versus human factors validation.

Figures

Figures the speakers cited

30 adults, 15 adolescents, 15 caregiversparticipants in the type 1 diabetes human factors validation case study
four and a half hourslength of each diabetes case-study session, including training, decay, and session conduct
3 to 6 participantsover-recruitment per user group in the diabetes case study
30-personpatient monitor validation study size in the pilot-session case study
3 monthstypical timeline for scoping, planning, recruitment, analysis, and reporting a human factors study
95%success-rate threshold that is not sufficient for interpreting human factors validation
four weekstypical minimum recruitment lead time mentioned for some populations

Source: Kira Favika

Chapters

Jump to a moment

  1. Housekeeping, speaker introductions, and why human factors planning matters
  2. Late human factors increases cost; early work de-risks validation
  3. Overview of six common planning and resourcing mistakes
  4. Mistake 1: poor scoping and UI alignment, with patient monitor case
  5. Mistake 2: project and resource mismanagement
  6. Mistake 3: recruitment planning and diabetes validation case
  7. Mistake 4: dry runs and pilot sessions, with patient monitor case
  8. Mistake 5: poorly trained personnel and robotic surgery case
  9. Mistake 6: analysis and reporting time; making the case to management

Times run from the start of the recording.

Slides 14

Slide 1

1 / 14

Take these with you

Six checks

Align scope and study goals earlyConfirm with R&D what parts of the user interface are under evaluation and why the study is being run before contracting.
Start recruitment earlyBuild recruitment lead time into the timeline instead of running it concurrently, and allow for at least several weeks.
Over-recruit and plan backfillsBudget backup participants and a clear day-of communication path for cancellations and no-shows.
Dry run and pilot the protocolPractice the script, tasks, equipment, and environment, then run a pilot session and leave time to update documents.
Use trained human factors personnelPut an experienced human factors moderator in place and train support staff, trainers, and observers to avoid bias.
Plan weeks for analysis and reportingReserve time for root-cause analysis, residual risk assessment, team alignment, and quality-system approval.

Full recording

57:29 · follow along with the transcript below

Plays from YouTube when you press play. Cookie settings

Transcript

Edited for readability · 9,153 words

00:06 · Denise Forkey
So just to give you guys some background, first of all, thanks for attending today.

00:10 · Denise Forkey
We're excited to share the webinar and if you have any follow-up questions or want to speak with us, we're more than happy to have follow-up conversations as well.

00:20 · Denise Forkey
So we, Kira and I were at a lunch at HFES with other human factors professionals and part of that conversation was, you know, I really wish my management understood what is actually involved in human factors validation studies.

How to cite this session

Forkey, D., Bergquist, L., Favakeh, K. (2026, August 6). Beyond the Protocol: A Realistic Resource and Planning Guide for Human Factors Validation Success [Webinar]. MedTech Leading Voice, MedTech Leading Voice. medtechleadingvoice.com/watch/2026-08-06-beyond-the-protocol-a-realistic-resource-and-planning-guide-for-human-factors-validation-success

Sponsored by ClariMed
Talk to the speakers about Beyond the Protocol: A Realistic Resource and Planning Guide for Human Factors Validation Success
Tell us what you're working on and the ClariMed team will get back to you.

Earlier sessions

13 Nov 2026Architecting a Claims Support System 6 Nov 2026Methodological Quality and Scientific Validity Under the MDR 30 Oct 2026AI Pre-Submission Review Under the MDR

Latest issues

Issue 190FDA and the Future of Generative AI Medical Devices Issue 189MDR and IVDR Evidence Requirements in Transition Issue 188Industry Groups Back a Single Regulatory Pathway for AI-Enabled Medical Devices